Natural Gas vs Propane Fire Pit: Which to Choose? (November 2026)
Choose natural gas for a permanent backyard pit with a fixed gas line, and propane for a portable pit you can move or take camping. In this natural gas vs propane fire pit comparison, the deciding factor is the fuel supply at your chosen spot.
On this page (9 sections)
- Natural gas vs propane fire pit: the quick verdict
- The two fuels side by side
- Which fuel should you choose for your backyard?
- Heat, flame and how each fuel burns
- Setup, storage and daily use
- Placement, portability and local rules
- Cost to buy and cost to run
- Who should buy which?
- The verdict: natural gas or propane?
Choose natural gas for a permanent backyard pit with a fixed gas line, and propane for a portable pit you can move or take camping. In this natural gas vs propane fire pit comparison, the deciding factor is the fuel supply at your chosen spot.
Propane arrives in a tank you refill and roll into place. Natural gas arrives through a line you have to install.
Everything else, from heat output to table design, follows that one difference.
The four gas fire pits below cover both routes: a natural gas build kit, portable propane bowls and tables, and a dual fuel table. Read on for the points that decide the choice.
Best for natural gas buildsonlyfire All-in-One Natural Gas Fire Pit Ignition
Natural gas vs propane fire pit: the quick verdict
For most backyard buyers, a propane fire pit is the easier first buy, because it needs no gas line work and you can move it. Choose natural gas when the pit will stay in one spot and you want to stop handling tanks.
A propane pit goes from the box to the patio in minutes. A natural gas pit needs a line run to the spot, usually by a licensed gas fitter, before the first burn.
If you're still deciding between table styles and bowl styles, our fire pit vs fire table comparison covers those shapes. The fuel question comes first, though, so start here.
The higher score in this comparison goes to the natural gas kit for anyone building a fixed pit. For everyone else, the propane options are the practical pick.
The two fuels side by side
Natural gas and propane deliver similar rated heat per burner, but they differ in supply, storage and installation. The table below sets the main differences next to each other.
| Point | Natural gas | Propane |
|---|---|---|
| Fuel supply | Permanent gas line from your home or a tank | Refillable tank you buy or swap |
| Installation | Line run to the pit, typically by a pro | None beyond connecting a tank |
| Portability | Fixed in one spot | Move it around or take it camping |
| Tank handling | None once the line is in | Swap or refill the tank |
| Typical cost | Lower fuel cost, higher install cost | Higher fuel cost, low startup cost |
| Where it works | Homes already connected to gas | Anywhere outdoors with a tank |
The rated heat is close. The onlyfire kit runs an electronic igniter and key valve on a natural gas line.
The Outland Living Firebowl pushes 58,000 BTU from a standard 20 lb tank on a 10-ft hose. In BTU terms, neither fuel has an automatic heat advantage.
One item in the table deserves more than a line. Propane and natural gas burners are built to different fuel pressures, so the parts inside a propane pit are not interchangeable with natural gas parts without the maker's own conversion kit.
That's why a dual fuel table is worth knowing about: the NICESOUL ships with a dual fuel gas and propane conversion valve, so the same table can take a tank now and a line later.
What changes is everything around the flame: how you turn it on, where it sits and what you do when the fuel runs low.
Which fuel should you choose for your backyard?
Pick the fuel by where the pit will live and how often you'll move it. A fixed spot with a gas line favors natural gas.
A spot you might rearrange favors propane.
Start with your yard. Is there a gas line near the patio, or would a fitter need to trench across the lawn or run pipe along the house?
That answer sets the cost and the timeline.
Next, think about how you'll use the pit. A permanent centerpiece that runs most evenings suits natural gas.
A pit you wheel onto the deck, pack for a campsite or shift out of the way when the kids play suits propane.
For a wider look at steel bowls, smokeless designs and gas tables, our outdoor fire pit guide lays out the options. Fuel choice narrows that list quickly.
One more thing to weigh is the shape of your space. A round bowl like the 24-inch Outland Living is easy to sit around from any side.
A rectangular table like the 42-inch NICESOUL or the 28-inch square Ciays wants a defined patio edge to sit against. Fuel gets you started, but the footprint decides whether the pit actually fits the way you sit outside.
When natural gas makes more sense
Natural gas wins when the pit stays put and the line cost is already covered. A permanent installation means no tank to store, swap or hide.
That matters for a built-in pit or a fire table that anchors a patio. The onlyfire kit bundles the electronic igniter and key valve you need to build around natural gas.
It includes a 5-ft PVC hose and weighs about 6.16 lb.
Check local rules before the line goes in. A licensed gas fitter handles the connection, and some areas require a permit.
Once the line and shutoff are set, evening fires become a switch away.
When propane makes more sense
Propane wins when the pit needs to move, or when there's no gas line nearby. A tank hides under the table or beside a bowl, so you don't pay for a line run.
The NICESOUL table shows the flexible route best. It runs on propane from its own tank table, yet it also supports natural gas, so you can start portable and switch later.
Our gas fire pit picks covers more models if you want to compare shapes.
Propane also travels. The Outland Living Firebowl needs no assembly and includes a cover and lava rocks, so it suits a deck, a campsite or a tailgate as well as a backyard.
Heat, flame and how each fuel burns
Rated BTU, not the fuel name, tells you how much heat a burner puts out. Both fuels produce a clean flame when the burner and regulator are set up correctly.
The Ciays table rates 50,000 BTU. So does the NICESOUL table.
The Outland Living bowl rates 58,000 BTU. That figure describes the burner's output, and it's the number to compare when you want more warmth.
What each burner actually gives you
The 58,000 BTU bowl is the warmest unit here by rating, and its burner and fasteners are stainless steel. The two 50,000 BTU tables sit a step below on paper, but they spread that heat across a wider surface area, which some people prefer for seating a group around.
Flame look is close. Both fuels burn with a steady flame over lava rocks or fire glass, and both can be turned down.
The NICESOUL table includes 8.8 lb of blue fire glass and a glass wind guard to keep the flame steady.
One real difference is smoke and soot. A properly adjusted gas burner runs clean either way.
A badly set burner can produce soot on either fuel, so follow the lighting and adjustment steps in the kit or table instructions.

A 24-inch propane bowl with 58,000 BTU and a 10-ft hose, so the tank stays out of sight and the pit moves where you do.
See it on AmazonSetup, storage and daily use
Propane is quicker to set up and natural gas is easier to live with once installed. The tradeoff is front-loaded: natural gas costs more up front and less effort afterward.
A propane table or bowl takes minutes. Connect the hose, open the valve and light the burner.
The Outland Living Firebowl comes with no assembly required and a pre-attached 10-ft hose.
The tables split on assembly. The NICESOUL fire pit arrives as a one-piece frame with only its tank table needing minimal assembly.
The Ciays table needs its connection checked before first use, and its manual asks for a soapy water leak test, which is the right habit for any new gas connection.
Then there's the tank. A standard 20 lb tank needs refilling or swapping, and it takes up space.
Some tables hide it in a tank table, as the NICESOUL design does. Others need the tank set beside the pit.
Natural gas skips the tank entirely. After the line is in, you light the burner and shut it off when you're done.
The onlyfire kit's key valve gives you a dedicated shutoff at the pit, which keeps daily use simple.
Storage follows the same split. A propane tank should stay upright and out of the weather when not in use.
A natural gas pit has no tank to store, so winter prep is mostly about covering the burner and shutting the valve.
Placement, portability and local rules
Portable propane pits go wherever you can carry them; natural gas pits stay where the line ends. Check local rules and clearances either way.
A propane pit suits a deck, a patio corner or a campsite. Move it out of the way for a party, or take the Outland Living bowl on a trip.
The tradeoff is that every move means checking the hose and tank.
Natural gas fixes the pit in one place. That's a strength for a built-in or a table you want to anchor.
It's a weakness if you like to rearrange the patio each season.
Local rules matter more than the fuel. Some communities restrict open flames during dry spells.
A covered gas burner on either fuel is usually easier to use than a wood fire in those periods. Check current restrictions in your area before you burn.
Clearance to walls, furniture and overhead structures comes from the instructions for your kit or table. Keep the tank upright and the hose clear of walkways on a propane setup.
Cost to buy and cost to run
Propane costs less to start; natural gas often costs less to run. The right choice depends on how often you'll light the pit and whether a gas line is already close.
A propane pit needs the appliance plus a tank and refills. A natural gas pit needs the appliance plus a line run.
The line is the big unknown, since it depends on distance, trenching and local labor rates.
Running costs favor natural gas in most areas, because utility gas typically costs less per unit of heat than tank refills. The gap matters most for a pit you light several times a week.
The tank maths is easy to picture. A full 20 lb tank holds about 430,000 BTU, so a 50,000 BTU table gives you roughly 8 to 9 hours on high.
If you run the fire twice a week for a few hours, you'll be refilling through the season. A natural gas line ends that errand, which is where much of its long-run value sits.
If you light the pit a few times a season and want to move it, the lower startup cost and flexibility of propane usually win. If the pit runs often and stays put, the natural gas line pays for itself over time.
Who should buy which?
Buy natural gas if the pit is permanent and a line is practical; buy propane if you want flexibility or no line work. Each product here fits one of those readers.

An all-in-one natural gas kit with an electronic igniter, key valve and 5-ft hose for a fixed backyard build.
See it on Amazon
A 42-inch dual fuel table that runs on propane or natural gas, with a glass wind guard and blue fire glass.
See it on Amazon
A 28-inch square propane table with lava rocks, a lid and external flame control for a compact patio.
See it on AmazonPick natural gas for a fixed backyard pit
The onlyfire kit is the natural gas pick for a custom build. It bundles the electronic igniter, key valve and hose, so you supply the structure and the gas line.
It's the strongest fit for a permanent pit you'll use often.
A dual fuel table is the second route. The NICESOUL 42-inch table supports both propane and natural gas, so you can start with a tank and connect a line later.
Our natural gas fire pits with glass guide covers more glass-topped options.
Pick propane for a portable or first pit
The Outland Living Firebowl is the easiest first pit. It's a 24-inch round bowl with 58,000 BTU, a 10-ft hose, lava rocks and a cover.
Set it on the patio or pack it for a trip.
The Ciays 28-inch table suits a smaller patio. Its lid turns it into a table when the fire is off, and the external flame control lets you dial the heat down.
It's propane only, so you'll handle the tank.
The verdict: natural gas or propane?
For most readers, a propane fire pit is the better first buy because it works without a gas line and moves with your plans. Choose natural gas when the pit is permanent and you'll run it often.
The split is simple. Propane suits renters, movers, campers and anyone without a nearby gas line.
Natural gas suits a fixed patio centerpiece where a fitter can run the line and you want to skip tank handling.
If you're unsure, a dual fuel table like the NICESOUL keeps both doors open. Start on a tank, switch to a line later.
Whichever you choose, check local rules, keep clearances and follow the instructions for your kit. For more options before you buy, browse our gas fire pit guides or compare table shapes in our fire pit vs fire table breakdown.
Frequently asked questions
Is a natural gas fire pit cheaper to run than propane?
Natural gas usually costs less per unit of heat than propane, so a fixed natural gas line often runs cheaper over time. The bigger costs are the gas line installation and the appliance itself.
Compare your local utility rate against the refill cost of a 20 lb propane tank before deciding.
Can I convert a propane fire pit to natural gas?
Only with a conversion kit made for that exact model. Some pits, like the Outland Living Firebowl, offer a matching natural gas conversion kit.
Burners, orifices and controls differ between fuels, so an unapproved swap can be unsafe.
Follow the manufacturer's kit instructions or use a licensed gas fitter.
How long does a 20 lb propane tank last on a fire pit?
A 20 lb tank holds roughly 430,000 BTU of propane. At a 50,000 BTU output, a full tank lasts about 8 to 9 hours on high, and longer at a lower flame.
Actual runtime depends on the setting, weather and how much heat you want.
Where can you put a propane fire pit?
A portable propane pit goes almost anywhere outdoors with a stable, level surface and clear space around the flame. That includes a patio, deck, campsite or tailgate.
Always keep the tank upright and follow the manufacturer's clearances and any local burn rules.
Do you need a professional to install a natural gas fire pit?
Running a gas line to a new fire pit is work for a licensed gas fitter or plumber in most areas. You can handle the burner and kit assembly yourself once the line and shutoff are in place.
Check local codes and permit rules before the line is run.
Which gives more heat, natural gas or propane?
Propane carries more energy per volume, but appliance output in BTU is what matters. A 50,000 BTU burner delivers the same rated heat on either fuel.
Compare BTUs across models rather than assuming one fuel is always hotter.
About this guide: Our look at natural gas vs propane fire pit comparison draws on maker specs, materials and what owners report. See how we research.



